Feature2011·95m·5.2

The Craigslist Killer

Be careful what you search for.

DramaThriller

Based on a true story, seemingly flawless Philip Markoff, a charismatic and popular medical student at Boston University, leads a double life and starts to descend into a twisted world of gambling, crime, battery, and eventually murder, all while meeting his victims via Craigslist.

Play now

Cast

Jake McDorman

Phillip Markoff

Agnes Bruckner

Megan McAllister

Julia Campbell

Susan McAllister

Kevin Kilner

David McAllister

Candice Patton

Kate

Judith Hoag

Patricia Banks

Sam McMurray

Dr. Janeway

Joshua Close

Detective Frye

Leela Savasta

Julissa Brisman

Trieste Kelly Dunn

Trisha Leffler

William Baldwin

Detective Bennett

Kerry Knuppe

Janet

Toby Meuli

Tom Wilson

Suzanne Quast

Amber

Alan Wells

Michael McAllister

Jhemma Ziegler

Monica

David Gautreaux

Police Profiler

Terri Hoyos

Sophie Flores

Greg Vrotsos

Burly Guy

Sandra Sanchez

Newscaster

Details

Status: Released
Original language: English
Languages: English
Budget: —
Revenue: —
Age rating: —
Quality: 4K UHD · HDR10 · Dolby Vision
Production: Peace Out ProductionsSilverScreen PicturesLifetime

Crew

Director

Stephen Kay

Writers

Donald Martin, Stephen Tolkin, Michele McPhee, Michele McPhee

Jamie Barber

Director of Photography

Hunter M. Via

Editor

Marek Dobrowolski

Production Design

Salvador Pérez Jr.

Costume Design

Tree Adams

Original Music Composer

Gallery

Reviews

Alunauwie

9/30/2025

5.0

The Craigslist Killer offers an intriguing premise based on a true crime, but focuses more on romantic drama than psychological tension, leaving its thriller potential underexplored. Weak character development and a lack of emotional depth hinder the impact of its core message—that people can hide dark secrets behind perfect facades. Though the story is systematic, its rushed resolution and unclear tone make it fall short of its gripping potential. Read the full review here: (Indonesian version : alunauwie.com) and (English version : uwiepuspita.com)